
One good fermentation is a result. Three fermentations that give the same result are a process, and only a process can be scaled, costed and sold.
The difference is not rhetorical. A single good batch says those performances are possible; it does not say how often they repeat. Before scale-up the question that matters is not what the best batch yielded, but how far independent batches sit from one another: the spread, not the mean.
It is measured by comparing independent batches: same strain, same medium, same procedure, but different days, different inocula, different operators. From there you obtain the spread of the quantities that count — titre, yield on substrate, volumetric productivity, consumption profile, fermentation time — expressed as a coefficient of variation rather than as the gap between the best and the worst case.
A titre quoted without a spread is a marketing number: it does not let you size a plant, write a specification or negotiate a supply agreement.
When the spread is wide, the causes concentrate in a few places: inoculum preparation and physiological state, raw material lot variability, pH and dissolved oxygen control at the limits of the system, the criterion and timing of induction or of the fed-batch start, and construct stability over generations when the strain is recombinant.
Chasing them one at a time is slow and expensive. A design of experiments moves several factors together on a plan and reads the interactions as well: fewer runs, and you find out which factors actually carry the process rather than which ones you happened to test first.
Before scale-up, not after the first disappointing batch at volume. It is a handful of fermentations against the cost of an out-of-specification industrial batch, and it is the part of the project that makes everything else transferable: without a declared spread, a process cannot be contracted out and cannot be defended in front of a customer.
The programme builds on strain and process development and continues on the pilot line up to 100 litres. Here is the rest of what we do in bioindustry R&D.
The service that puts this programme into practice is fermentation process development.
Technical content and news from our laboratories, sent when there is something worth saying.