{"id":15159,"date":"2026-11-15T12:36:24","date_gmt":"2026-11-15T11:36:24","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/bict.it\/?p=15159"},"modified":"2026-11-15T12:37:03","modified_gmt":"2026-11-15T11:37:03","slug":"e-factor-pmi-biocatalysis","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/bict.it\/en\/e-factor-pmi-biocatalysis\/","title":{"rendered":"E-factor and PMI: measuring whether a biocatalytic process is really greener"},"content":{"rendered":"

An enzymatic route can cut the waste of a pharmaceutical process several-fold. The number that proves it, however, is built before the comparison, not after: if the boundaries of the mass balance shift between the chemical and the enzymatic route, the result says more about the accounting than about the chemistry.<\/p>\n

Whoever has to decide whether to replace a step needs a figure that holds up in front of production, purchasing and the sustainability report. In our biocatalytic development<\/a> work we set it up this way: a mass balance per unit operation on the existing route and on the enzymatic one, the same boundaries for both, and the techno-economic assessment alongside.<\/p>\n

Two metrics, one mass balance<\/h2>\n

Sheldon’s E-factor is kg of waste per kg of product. Process Mass Intensity (PMI), adopted by the ACS GCI Pharmaceutical Roundtable, puts everything that goes in on top: reagents, reaction and purification solvents, catalysts, water. Count the same materials and PMI = E + 1. The ideal is 1 for PMI and 0 for the E-factor.<\/p>\n

Pharmaceuticals start from an E-factor of 25 to over 100 kg\/kg, against less than 0.1 in oil refining. The reason is nearly always the same: solvents make up to 80-90% of the non-aqueous mass used to manufacture an API.<\/p>\n

When water enters the count<\/h2>\n

Biocatalysis often runs in aqueous buffer, and here the metric can turn against the enzyme. The E-factor was born without water; in pharma the trend today is to include it. The enzymatic process for the atorvastatin intermediate has an E-factor of 5.8 without process water and 18 with it. Both are correct. Comparing one with the other is not.<\/p>\n

The same goes for solvents. Sheldon separates the simple E-factor (sEF, no solvents or water), useful for route scouting, from the complete one (cEF, all materials, no recycling), useful for waste-stream analysis; the industrial figure falls in between. For sildenafil the two values, on the same process, are 3.9 and 50.3. A comparison with an sEF on one side and a cEF on the other moves the verdict by an order of magnitude.<\/p>\n

What about the enzyme?<\/h2>\n

The most common objection is a fair one: the enzyme has to be expressed and purified, and fermentation uses water, media and energy. Becker, L\u00fctz and Rosenthal measured the lab-scale production of 10 g of a recombinant enzyme: about 37,800 g of waste per gram of enzyme and 603 kWh of electricity. Their conclusion is that this contribution should not be neglected.<\/p>\n

That burden, though, is divided by the grams of product each gram of enzyme converts. In the atorvastatin process the enzymes and the cofactor account for less than 1% of the waste: at the stated loadings, about 280 g of substrate per gram of ketoreductase. The levers are enzyme loading, residual activity at the end of the reaction, and reuse. And a lab figure is not an industrial one: the same authors estimate that a ten-fold higher cell density would bring energy down to about 200 kWh.<\/p>\n

Where the gain really is<\/h2>\n

Again in the atorvastatin case, 51% of the waste comes from solvent losses, 25% from gluconate and 22% from salts. Once the enzyme is in place, what remains sits in the work-up: extractions, solvent swaps, crystallisations.<\/p>\n

The advantage of an enzymatic step is therefore often measured in the steps around it: one protection fewer, no metal to remove, a crystallisation saved. That is why the comparison is made on the whole route, which is the ground of chemo-enzymatic processes<\/a>. The reference case agrees: the sitagliptin transaminase process cut total waste by 19%, and the real gain was also in yield and in removing rhodium.<\/p>\n

What PMI does not see<\/h2>\n

PMI and E-factor weigh kilograms, not hazard or energy: a kilogram of dichloromethane and a kilogram of brine count the same. The numbers should be read with a solvent selection guide and, when the choice matters, with a life cycle assessment. They remain the first filter, and the cheapest: they can be calculated from lab data in the first weeks, before scale-up.<\/p>\n

In our projects the count follows three rules:<\/p>\n